R/r/w/F collapse into G and g over a selector byte naming the space — flash,
EEPROM, data, fuse, SPM — with the flash bank in its high nibble. Four command
bodies, four transfer loops and four argument decodes become one of each, and
W joins the same decode instead of keeping an address form of its own. The
loader shrinks while gaining everything below: on the 1284P the stock build
goes 480 -> 432 B and the software one 496 -> 450.
What the freed space buys:
- Data space. On AVR one pointer spans SRAM, the register file and the whole
I/O space, so G over space 2 reads all three. pureboot keeps zero static
RAM and pushes no register, so at loader entry an application's SRAM is
still what the application left there — this is a post-mortem, not just a
poke hole. As its own command it needed a dispatch arm and a loop; as one
more space it is a single ld/st.
- Host-issued SPM. W fills the page buffer and stops; erase, write and RWW
re-enable are writes to space 4, which reach the same fused store-and-SPM
pair through the transfer's own address and data. Any SPM operation, lock
bits included, is now reachable and the loader carries no page-commit logic.
The four-cycle SPMCSR-to-SPM window is why that primitive stays fused: no
host can hit it across a serial link, and that — not the byte count — is
the floor on how low-level a bootloader's primitives can go.
- Byte addresses everywhere. The bank in the selector retires the
word-addressed wire the >64 KiB parts needed, so the 1284s stop being the
outlier.
SERIAL autobaud is a third backend on the same loader, over libavr's
software_autobaud: no clock, no baud, one binary per chip for every F_CPU and
every rate. Activation counts poll iterations rather than seconds and bounds
every wait, so a stray pulse cannot hold an unattended device.
b answers with the version and signature only; the host derives geometry from
the signature, which is what an autobaud build requires anyway. An update image
is a bare slot with no device to ask, so every image carries a six-byte stamp —
the same bytes b answers with, and the source of both — that the loader never
reads from flash and the host refuses to install a mismatch against. The
running-slot write guard moved onto the SPM commit, which covers erase and
write both where guarding W covered neither directly.
The position-independence lint now proves the property instead of a proxy for
it: the image must come out byte-identical linked at a different base.
-fno-move-loop-invariants left the tuned flag set — it was fitted to a command
loop carrying four transfer bodies and costs bytes now that it carries one.
Verified: the exhaustive matrix on all 37 chips (every clock x every baud x
every backend, non-standard rates included, plus the autobaud build) —
8174 size checks, no failures, tightest fit the 1284s' autobaud at 510 of 512.
Behavioral suites green on every chip class: t13a 10/10, t85 11/11, m8 13/13,
m16a 13/13, m48pa 13/13, 328P 23/23, 644A 17/17, 1284P 17/17. Data-space
round trip through --peek/--poke and the autobaud handshake are both red-green
proven.
The two prototype sources and their findings file go; the README carries the
protocol and dev/done.md in libavr carries the reasoning.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Hardware testing found that a lone calibration pulse wedged the autobaud loader:
run() budgeted only the start-edge wait in measure(), and the rx() that read the
knock behind it was unbudgeted, so one stray low pulse held an unattended device
in the loader and the application never ran. Bound the whole activation — an
expired knock budget returns a byte that cannot be the knock, so control falls
back into the budgeted measure() and an idle line boots the app there.
That fix costs ~22 B, which neither version under review could absorb: the pure
one goes 508 -> 530 on the 1284P and the register one 512 -> 534, both over a
512 B slot. Their margin was never spare capacity, it was the space the missing
fix should have occupied. So the choice between them is moot; both are kept for
the record and no longer built.
pureboot_autobaud_uni.cpp replaces them at 464 B. It is pureboot 5: one read
command and one write command over named spaces (G/g, sel8, addr16, n8) instead
of four per-memory bodies, which collapses four transfer loops into one. The
selector's high nibble carries flash's bank, so the shared cursor stays 16 bits
and no command speaks word addresses. Three things fall out of the freed space:
RAM read/write — the missing feature, and with it arbitrary I/O access, since
AVR maps peripherals into the data space; host-issued SPM, so W's hardcoded
erase/write/RWW tail becomes three writes to a space and any SPM operation is
reachable; and W on the same selector-and-address decode as everything else.
Strictly pure throughout: no inline asm, no global register variable, and no
GPIOR either — the unit lives in a .noinit static, so the loader claims no chip
resource and the chips without GPIOR stop being a special case.
pureboot.py speaks both generations, keyed on the version, so the fixed-baud
path is untouched; --peek/--poke reach the new data space. pbautobaud.py adds a
RAM round-trip and a regression for the hang: a lone pulse must still let the
app boot. All 37 chips plus the 12-preset reflect spot set build and size-test
green, 444-466 B, worst case 46 B under budget. Sim suites 100%: 1284P 17/17,
328P 23/23. Only real-hardware acceptance remains (pureboot/autobaud.md).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
pureboot.py --autobaud sends the 0xC0 calibration pulse and a single knock at
the host's chosen baud, reads the slimmed info block, and derives the full
geometry from the signature (AUTOBAUD_GEOMETRY, a table over every pureboot
chip). Everything downstream — flash, EEPROM, fuses, hand-over, verify — is the
fixed-baud path unchanged; the dropped write guard is host-transparent.
test/pbautobaud.py drives each variant over the GPIO⇄pty software-UART bridge
through the calibration handshake and a flash + EEPROM + fuse round-trip
cross-checked against the simulator's ground-truth memory, then repeats at
double the F_CPU with the same binary — the clock-agnostic property autobaud
exists for. Wired as pureboot.autobaud_pure/reg on the near-flash 328P and the
word-addressed 1284P. A wrong measured unit fails the flash/verify, so the test
also pins the codegen-coupled calibration constant against a toolchain bump.
Both variants green in sim on both chips at two clocks each; the fixed-baud
suite is unaffected. Only real-hardware acceptance on an RC part remains
(pureboot/autobaud.md).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The unaligned-W and U2X-hand-over fixes change the loader's observable
on-wire behavior, and the --stay reconnect fix changes the host tool, so
both move: loader version 3 -> 4, tool VERSION 2 -> 3. The protocol and info
block are unchanged, so OLDEST_LOADER stays 1.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
A prompt byte alone does not: one left over from a previous session can
still be in the pipeline while the port opening resets the device into a
fresh window, where the bare command that follows is discarded. Each
attempt is now the whole handshake, retried until the block comes back.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The word-addressed 1284s were the one family deploying in a 1 KiB slot,
because the far-flash machinery (ELPM reads, RAMPZ page commands, a
word-addressed wire) did not fit 512 B. It does now: 478 B stock, 494 B in
the heaviest configuration the build can produce. They take the 644s'
geometry, where the smallest boot section holds the resident slot and its
staging slot together. The loader's version goes to 3; the host tool did
not change, so its own version stays 2 and only the window it speaks
widens.
Most of the saving is one restructure. The info block and a flash read are
the same act, so giving all four streamed commands one address-and-count
path leaves exactly one call site for the flash streamer: it inlines into
the never-returning command loop and its 24-bit cursor stops being saved
and restored around every transmit. Around it, the ack byte moved out of
line, the wire's byte pair is bit_cast into the word it already is, the
fuse loop ends on its count, the info block's in-slot offset is taken as
the one-byte relocation it is, and -fno-expensive-optimizations gives way
to -fno-move-loop-invariants -fno-tree-ter. Every chip shrank 14-18 B.
The size matrix grew the axes it was missing: the USART1 instance across
the whole clock ladder, and the shape a slow baud gives a software UART —
past 255 delay iterations libavr takes the 16-bit delay loop, which the
ladder default never selects and which was 4 B over the 1284's slot the
first time it was built.
The protocol fixture stopped deriving the loader entry from the flash
size; on the 1284s it had been jumping a slot low and reaching the loader
only because erased flash walked it up.
Docs and comments were consolidated across the port in the same pass: the
README carries a per-chip size table instead of prose, and prose that
restated the code is gone — 190 lines, no behaviour with it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The info block's third byte was a protocol version that never moved in the
loader's lifetime. It is the pureboot version now, and this change is
version 2: the one number that says what a deployed loader is. Every loader
already in the field answers 1.
The protocol keeps no number of its own — a pureboot version implies it, and
the host tool is what holds that map. pureboot.py states the loader-version
window it speaks (OLDEST_LOADER/NEWEST_LOADER; a version that changes the
protocol becomes the new floor there), so a loader newer than the tool is
refused by name rather than decoded on the assumption nothing moved, while an
older one is read, identified and installed like any other. The tool carries
its own version, free to drift from the loader's: --version prints it and the
window, --info leads with the device's, --update-loader names the version it
installs.
Tests: the planner unit pins the window — every version in it decodes, one
above it is refused, an older loader's image is still found — and the live
suite pins the built loader against the tool beside it, so a bump that reaches
only one of them fails. The image is byte-identical to the previous build but
for that byte.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The temporary page buffer is write-once per word, so a page filled over
one an earlier writer left dirty programs the stale words. The same
datasheet clause carries the cure: the buffer auto-erases after a page
write (§26.2.1; §19.2 on the tinies), so the corruption clears itself by
happening, and rewriting the page programs correctly.
The loader therefore clears the buffer nowhere. The tinies' CTPB and the
m48s' RWWSRE discard are gone; the boot-sectioned megas keep only the
trailing RWWSRE they need anyway to re-enable the RWW section for
read-back, which discards the buffer as a side effect and keeps them off
the path entirely. 434 B on the tiny13s, 438-442 on the tiny25/45/85,
430 on the m48s; the megas are unchanged, the 1284s still 506.
The host takes over the guarantee: a flash page that reads back wrong is
rewritten up to RETRIES times before the run stops. Both read-back paths
repair — verify_pages for programming, and write_differing, which is the
loader-update path where a page left wrong is a half-written loader slot.
That one is not hypothetical: deleting the discard made attiny85
pureboot.rehome fail deterministically there, the only flow still
assuming the old contract.
Protocol-visible, so README's W command says it: one W may program the
wrong bytes after a refused page, or after an application that
self-programmed entered without a reset, and a host that programs without
reading back cannot trust it.
Tests: pureboot.dirty drives the case the loader declines to guard — the
fixture application dirties every buffer word and jumps in with no reset
(hardware forbids that on a boot-sectioned mega, but simavr dispatches SPM
from anywhere, which is what makes it constructible) — and asserts a bare
verify sees the corruption, the repairing verify fixes it in one rewrite,
and it stays fixed. pbreloc asserts the same shape after a refusal.
test_planner covers the bound against a fake device: one bad write
repaired in a single rewrite, a page that never comes good stopping after
exactly three.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
--info prints the decoded info block field by field and --fuses each
byte on its own line plus the BOOTSZ/BOOTRST meaning on boot-sectioned
megas. Transfers that take wire time draw a transient progress bar on
stderr when it is a tty — logs, pipes and the tests see only the
summary lines. -v/--verbose narrates decisions: knock counts, the
programming plan, update state handling and per-phase page counts.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The update flow's first step wrote the staging content over whatever the
staging slot held; with a loader running right there (programmed by hand
onto erased flash), that write met the copy's own running-slot guard on
the composed through-word and the tool stopped at its verify — although
the copy is exactly an installed staging copy, able to stream the new
resident like any other. The install is now skipped when the slot holds a
complete loader: its info block where every image carries it, matching
the device's byte for byte, and the slot unchanged since the update began
(the state file's snapshot) — so a resumed half-written install still
differs from its snapshot and takes the install path, which completes it.
pbrehome gains the staging-slot position (an older build at stage
streaming a newer resident in); the README's wrong "cannot re-home from
the staging slot" claim is corrected.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The chip table becomes family blocks covering all 37 targets. The m48s
are a new deployment class: no boot section, so the tiny profile spoken
over the hardware USART — host-patched reset vector, trampoline
hand-over, a 510-byte budget (474 B built), no fuse preflight — while
their RWWSRE store stays the buffer discard (Atmel-8271 §26.2); the
device keys the patch flag and the CPU-halt waits on the curated
boot-section capability and the discard on the RWWSRE bit itself. The
644s' 64 KiB is exactly the 16-bit byte space: plain LPM, byte wire
addresses, 498 B in a 512-byte slot — and their 1 KiB minimum boot
section holds the resident and staging slots together, so self-update
needs no fuse step (the update test's slot pick now keys word-flash on
base >= 64 KiB; base + slot merely touching the boundary stays
byte-addressed). The 1284 joins the 1284P's word-addressed 1 KiB slot at
558 B. BOOT_FUSE gains every boot-sectioned family's ladder and fuse
byte; the planner exercises them all. The sim scaffolding keys
patch-vector-ness instead of the atmega name prefix, the fixture app
picks its clock by family (the tiny25/45/13 builds surfaced the 16 MHz
fallthrough as garbled banners), and the runner's wrapped flash ioctl
performs the m48 discard simavr's no-RWW cores turn into a stray buffer
fill. Sizes across the fleet: 466-504 B megas, 474 B m48s, 498 B 644s,
488-502 B tinies, 558 B 1284s — every chip passing
size/pi/planner/protocol/reloc/update.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The far machinery (ELPM reads, RAMPZ page commands, wire-word math)
costs ~46 B over the m328P's 504, and the tsb-calibrated C++-to-asm
gap says no implementation of this feature set reaches 512 on this
chip — a boundary its hardware does not have anyway: the 1284P's
smallest boot sector is 1 KiB. The slot therefore becomes
per-geometry (512 B, or 1 KiB past 64 KiB), which the host derives
from the word-addressing flag; slot arithmetic unifies (the index is
the wire high byte with its low bit dropped in either unit), the
update preflight demands a two-slot boot section in the chip's own
terms, and pbapp's hand-back jumps to the real slot base. libavr's
far primitives split their RAMPZ/Z asm operands (a page never
crosses 64 KiB, so callers keep a byte and a 16-bit cursor — the
32-bit address folds away; flash_load_far's byte form becomes the
out-RAMPZ+elpm pair avr-libc's pgm_read_byte_far rebuilds per call),
and the host splits reads at 64 KiB boundaries. All ten chips pass
the full suite — the 1284P at 558 B including protocol, relocation,
and the power-fail self-update — with pureboot byte-identical across
generated and reflect modes everywhere, and the original three
chips' images unchanged to the byte (488/502/504).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Device: boot-section detection probes SPMCR beside SPMCSR, the link
picks any hardware USART through the instance-aware lookups (URSEL
chips included), WDRF reads MCUSR-or-MCUCSR, and the >64 KiB shape
lands — word-addressed wire flash (info flag bit 1, page byte 0 means
256, base as a word address), far reads through flash_load_far, a
single 32-bit byte-cursor page walk (the 256-byte page wraps its low
byte exactly), and slot arithmetic in words (the return address
already is one). Host: addresses stay bytes internally and scale at
the wire, the boot-fuse decode becomes a per-signature table (byte
index + BOOTSZ ladder — the m168A's lives in EXTENDED), and the
planner tests pin every chip's ladder plus the word-addressed info
decode. Tests: the device runner serves every mega over the USART pty,
pbapp banners over the right link, the update rehearsal synthesizes
its assumed fuses from the tool's own table, and the PI lint tracks
the renamed info symbol. All six classic-mega/168A targets pass the
full suite (size, PI, planner, protocol, reloc, self-update) at
466–504 B; the 1284P builds await a libavr far-path slimming to make
its 512.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The build emits an Intel HEX beside every loader image, but --update-loader
could not consume one: load_image() anchors every image at address zero, and
a loader HEX links at its base, so it decoded to a 32760-byte blob carrying
504 bytes of loader at the end. staging_content() then refused it as "loader
image is 32760 B, the slot holds 512" - an error naming neither the cause nor
the raw .bin the tool wanted instead.
Drop the blank below the base in the update path. The base comes from the
image's own info block rather than the device's, so an image built for
another target survives the slice intact and the preflight still reports it
as another target rather than failing to find an info block at all.
Verified on an ATmega328P: the full self-update flow driven straight from
pureboot_timeout-5s.hex, resident slot byte-for-byte against the image
afterwards, application preserved; both refusal paths unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The host tool was standard-library-only but POSIX-only with it: termios and
select() bound the port layer, and importing termios failed outright on
Windows, so the module could not even load there.
Split Port into PosixPort (unchanged) and a WindowsPort over the Win32 serial
API through ctypes, picked by os.name; every call site keeps the Port name.
kernel32 only, so the standard-library constraint holds.
Windows has no select() for a COM handle, so the read deadlines move into the
driver as COMMTIMEOUTS, re-armed per read: read_available() ends on a gap
longer than a USB-serial latency timer coalesces (16 ms on FTDI parts),
read_exact() on the count or its deadline. Opening asserts DTR and RTS as a
POSIX open does, so a board wiring DTR to reset still pulses it. A failed
configuration closes the handle before raising - a COM handle is exclusive,
and the leak met the next open as "Access is denied". Win32 takes any integer
baud and a driver may accept one its hardware cannot produce (an FT232R
reports back a baud of 3 and keeps the old divisor), so obvious nonsense is
refused where termios' table would have.
Tested against an ATmega328P on COM6: info, fuses, both memories programmed
and verified, session reconnect, hand-over, the loader self-update, and the
write guard on its own slot. test_planner runs on Windows now as well.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The image now runs from any 512-byte slot with every command intact:
control flow stays PC-relative, the write guard keys on the running slot
(the return-address anchor, computed once), the info block is addressed
from that same anchor as a byte pair (no absolute 16-bit address in the
image), and the application jump is an indirect call through a noipa-
laundered pointer to the absolute entry. 'J' — jump to a wire word
address, the one transfer primitive — replaces 'G': the host knows the
application entry from the info block, and moving between loader copies
needs arbitrary targets. The activation window is a compile-time 8 s
(PUREBOOT_TIMEOUT overrides), counted as a single calibrated poll loop.
A refused page no longer poisons the write-once temporary buffer (a real
silicon trap: the next write would program the drained data): every page
write discards the buffer first — CTPB on the tinies, on the mega the same
RWWSRE store that re-enables RWW after programming. The tinies' post-op
busy-waits go with it: their CPU halts through page erase and write.
488 / 502 / 504 B on t13a / t85 / mega — under the tinies' 510-byte budget,
whose last slot word is the host-managed trampoline: the resident's holds
the application entry, a staging copy's the jump through which an abandoned
update still times out into a loader.
The host tool updates the loader with itself: --update-loader installs the
identical image one slot below the resident, jumps into it, lets it rewrite
the resident, and restores the staging region from a state file — each
phase idempotent off the flash state, resumable after any interruption
(t13a: the staging slot carries the reset vector, written last in and
first out; t85: word 0 redirected around the resident rewrite; mega:
fuse-matrix preflight with a hard BOOTSZ gate and --assume-fuses for
simulators). Application flashing recovers by reset from any interruption:
patched page 0 and trampoline first, erase descending, and a walk-region
refusal behind --force on BOOTRST-below-loader megas.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
pureboot.py: reject an empty image file with a clear error instead of
an IndexError deep in the vector-surgery planner; tighten the erase
docstring (order is irrelevant there — every target byte is the same
value, unlike a real flash where page 0 must go last).
pureboot_device.c: the GPIO bridge's bit_cycles used plain truncating
division where the firmware computes its own bit period with
round-to-nearest (uart.hpp: (Clock.hz + Baud.bd/2)/Baud.bd) — one
cycle off per bit on both tinies, harmless in practice but needless
drift against a firmware built to a different constant. Matched
exactly. Also clear the queued-bytes/decode-in-progress bridge state
on the test-only reset signal, so a future reset-mid-transfer scenario
can't feed a freshly reset chip bytes queued for its previous life.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
pureboot.py (Python stdlib only): images as raw binary or Intel HEX,
flash and EEPROM programming with read-back verify, erase composites,
fuse and info readout, activation-timeout configuration, and the
tinies' reset-vector surgery — the trampoline word below the loader,
page 0 written last.
The test spawns a simavr device (pureboot_device.c) — the mega's USART
as a pty; on the tinies a cycle-timed GPIO<->pty bridge for the polled
software UART plus the NVM module simavr's tiny cores lack (their SPM
opcode ioctls into a void and silently does nothing) — and drives it
with the real tool: knock from reset (erased-flash walk on the tinies),
program and verify both memories, timeout write, session reconnect, an
external reset through the patched vector, hand-over, and the fixture
application's banner. Results are cross-checked against ground-truth
memory dumps and an independent decode of the surgery's rjmp words,
red-verified against a sabotaged encoder.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
