The slot-survives-erase check reads back over ISP by design — an independent
reader is the only witness worth having about a loader that has just been
asked to erase around itself. With the one probe on another board it printed
"ISP read failed" as a red, which is the same word a destroyed loader would
get, and it is permanently red on the two deployments with no ISP header at
all.
It names its witness now and falls back to the link when there is no
programmer, saying that the loader is then reporting on its own slot — weaker
for exactly the reason it is worth having, since a destroyed loader could not
answer at all. An absent instrument is a fact about the bench and a wrong byte
is a verdict on the subject; a check that prints them identically stops being
read.
Both paths exercised on hardware: ISP on the Uno, the link on the ATtiny13A.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
'W' handed the loader a whole page with no ack inside it and sp_spm handed any
wire byte to SPMCSR, so a dropped byte re-aligned the stream and page data
arrived where commands belong. That is how a page-address byte became
BLBSET|SELFPRGEN on the tempmon board and programmed its lock bits.
The first answer was to refuse that one command. It was the wrong shape twice
over: it forbade a lock-bit write the owner may want, and it left every other
command decided by bytes nobody checked. v9 checks them instead. One header for
every command — opcode, selector, address, count, seal — folded and compared
before the command is decoded, and *answered* before any payload moves: '+'
accepts, 0xd4 (the ack inverted) refuses and nothing happened. An ack cannot do
this job; it reports a command that has already run.
It is smaller than v8 everywhere: 1284P 506→480, m8 498→480, 328P 484→468,
t13A 474→460. The seal costs 14 bytes; bit opcodes in place of the letters pay
for it twice over, since a letter costs a compare and a branch where a bit costs
a skip. Both guards go — the lock-bit refusal because the seal covers it, the
running-slot write guard because what it defended against was a wire fault
naming an address and a wire fault can no longer name one. That one is a real
trade: a host bug aimed at the running slot now lands. It buys a resident copy
that can write its own slot, which is the only self-update route on a chip whose
boot section *is* the slot.
Two things the tests caught, both introduced here. Removing the invalid-opcode
arm made every byte a command, so the knock stopped being harmless against a
loader already in session and ate the five bytes behind it — identify moves to
bit 5, which both 'p' and 'b' carry, so the knock is inert again and version
discovery still works before the version is known. And the SPM value rides the
count field because a data byte would arrive after the seal was checked.
pbselfwrite and pbglitch are the new gates, both red-green: the same erase of
the running page refused unsealed and performed sealed, and every header byte
damaged after sealing refused where the identical damage before sealing is
obeyed. Both judge by the simulator's flash, not the loader's opinion of it.
pbreloc and pbrehome lose their write-guard probes, which is what those two
gates replace. Defeating the seal in the loader turns seven tests red.
37 of 37 chips green with the exhaustive size matrix; README protocol section
and every size row rewritten. pbhw gains an adversarial --seal-rounds sweep for
the bench.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Its comment said "opening the port does not reset a board whose DTR is
unwired, so this simply listens" — true of the tiny it was written against,
false of an Arduino, and this is the generic harness. Where DTR is wired to
reset, that open resets the part and the activation window comes first, so a
fixture emitting its banner once says it on the far side of a wait the suite
cannot know the length of: the window is a compile-time constant and nothing
on the wire reports it. The suite read the silence as an application that
never ran, on a board where it demonstrably had.
So --marker-wait, defaulting to the 2.5 s that was hardcoded, and a failure
that names the window as the candidate rather than leaving the next person to
suspect the loader. The other half is the fixture: PUREBOOT_HEARTBEAT makes
the observation independent of when the listener arrives, which is what the
rig's own builds now pass.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The flag was plumbed through pbrig.Deployment to the host-tool subprocess
calls and nowhere else, so identity() and scan() opened a raw port and drove
a shared line as though it were two wires. On real one-wire hardware the
adapter's echo answers the knock before the device does, so the suite would
have died at its very first check — "the loader never answered; nothing below
can be trusted" — for the one deployment the flag exists to test, and every
result after it is gated on that check passing.
Both now open through pbrig.Rig.open_port(), which applies the deployment's
link mode. The gap underneath was that only the subprocess path could reach
those facts at all; anything driving the protocol in-process had to restate
them, and did not.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A rig hiccup mid-walk records the scan check as failed and lets the suite
continue, matching its siblings' envelope; a nonexistent --port path
reports as an error instead of a traceback.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
--scan's walk was unwalkable on POSIX: probe rates have no termios
B-constant, so the first off-nominal probe raised out of the loop. The port
speaks termios2 BOTHER now (red-proven on a pty at 9984 Bd), the probe's
open lives inside the walk's error handling, an fd no longer leaks on an
unmakeable rate, and the swallowed unknown-signature reply is named at
timeout instead of reported as silence. CMakePresets.json's generator emits
the submodule toolchain path it had drifted from — a hand edit on a
generated file, exactly the class rule 10 exists for — and presets.generated
gates the pair from here on (the marker CMake rejects at the
presets root stayed out; the check is the guard). The over-slot image guard
the tsb runner gained reaches the pureboot runner too; the GPIO bridge's
delivery comment states the hardware truth (RXC at the stop bit's sampling
point); the hardware suite gains the scan check — the one place the rate
physics is real; and the libavr pin advances over both audit rounds.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
check.sh proves the protocol under simavr on every chip; it cannot prove a
board. Two things live only on silicon — an RC oscillator that is not on its
nominal, and a reset edge that has to come from somewhere — and until now the
scripts that reached them were per-session scratch on the machine holding the
programmer, which is where the ATtiny13A run's findings nearly stayed.
pbrig.py is the primitives, knowing nothing per-board: every deployment fact is
a flag or a PUREBOOT_* variable. Two rig facts are encoded in it because neither
is guessable and each cost a session to learn: an ISP access *is* the reset edge
where the adapter's DTR is unwired, so a session begins with an ISP touch and
knocks immediately after; and avrdude splits -U on colons, so a Windows drive
letter breaks the spec and every file goes as a bare name with avrdude run in
its own directory. Its `rate` subcommand is the one that turns "the loader is
silent, so the wiring must be wrong" into a number, by sweeping the host rate
against a fixed cycles-per-bit transmitter — PUREBOOT_HEARTBEAT makes the
existing fixture into one, software link only, since the hardware-link idle owes
the self-update tests its command loop.
pbhw.py takes every bound from the info block the loader reports, so one run
covers a 1 KiB tiny and a 128 KiB mega alike. Both are exercised on an ATtiny13A:
backup verified against a known-good capture, the clock measured at 9.048 MHz
against a 9.6 MHz nominal, and the suite 11/11.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
