ide: the Atmel Studio solution master has, on the libavr port

master carries bootloader.atsln, so main does too. Two projects, because a
.cppproj is one binary at one flag set and this build has hundreds: the stock
328P pureboot loader (USART0 at 115200 on a 16 MHz crystal), and the tsb_asm
tier that occupies the same 512-byte section master's own tsb project targeted.
Both come out byte-identical to the Ninja build — 404 B and 510 B of .text —
in both configurations.

Debug keeps -Os and adds only -gdwarf-4. A loader's section is a correctness
bound, and -Og builds this source to 590 B: the link at 0x7e00 accepts that
without a diagnostic, 78 bytes past flash end, where rcall/rjmp wrap modulo
flash size and the image dies just after activation. Debug info costs no flash,
so the optimisation level stays where correctness needs it.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-07-27 22:11:28 +02:00
parent af0dd15a77
commit 3ce817ea03
5 changed files with 337 additions and 1 deletions

78
ide/README.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,78 @@
# Atmel Studio
`master` carries `bootloader.atsln`, so this branch does too: `ide/bootloader.atsln`
builds the loaders from the same sources Ninja does, to a **byte-identical
`.text`** — 404 B for the 328P pureboot loader, 510 B for the `tsb_asm` tier in
its 512-byte section. CMake remains the build system; the solution is here so the
port opens in Studio as its predecessor did.
## The two projects, and why two
pureboot is a chip × backend × clock × baud matrix — `pureboot_add_loader()`
resolves a deployment into compile definitions — and a `.cppproj` is one binary
at one set of flags, so a project can only ever be one point of it. `pureboot`
is that point: the stock 328P deployment, USART0 at 115200 on a 16 MHz crystal,
an 8-second activation window. `tsb_asm` is the TinySafeBoot tier that occupies
the same 512-byte section `master`'s `tsb` project targeted.
The other three tsb tiers (`tsb_pure`, `tsb_tricks`, `tsb_policy`) are not here.
They differ from `tsb_asm` in their source file, their section size, and — for
`tsb_policy` — two loop flags; nothing about that is a Studio concern, and what
they exist to demonstrate is a size gradient only the CMake size tests measure.
Adding one is a copy of `tsb_asm/tsb_asm.cppproj` in its own directory, with its
name, its GUID, its source path and its `--section-start` changed (`0x7c00` for
the 1 KiB tiers), plus four lines in the solution.
`avrdevice` is a project property, so each project gets its own directory:
Studio builds into `<project dir>/<Configuration>` whatever `OutputDirectory`
says, and two projects sharing a directory would share one object file.
## Debug keeps `-Os`
Both configurations compile at `-Os`; Debug adds only `-gdwarf-4`. The `.text`
is therefore identical in both, which is the point — a loader's section is a
**correctness** bound and not a budget. `-Og` builds this same source to 590 B,
and linking it at `--section-start=.text=0x7e00` on a 32 KiB part puts 78 bytes
past flash end **without a diagnostic**: `rcall`/`rjmp` targets there wrap
modulo flash size, so the image dies right after activation. A debug
configuration that silently produces that is worse than none, and DWARF costs no
flash, so the optimisation level stays where correctness needs it.
## What Studio needs from the machine
libavr checked out **beside this repo**, found at
`$(MSBuildProjectDirectory)\..\..\..\libavr\include` — anchored to the project,
because a plain relative path resolves against the generated makefile's
directory (the configuration's output directory), not the project's. There is no
`LIBAVR_ROOT` escape hatch: a variable exported in a shell is invisible to Studio
launched from the Start menu, and the failure reads as a missing
`libavr/libavr.hpp`. Pinning libavr as a submodule is the better answer and is on
libavr's task list.
A GCC 16.1 toolchain registered as flavour `avr-g++-16.1.0`, nothing older
reaching `-std=c++26`.
## Generating and gating
One generated file is required before a project will load at all, and one command
per project checks the flags have not drifted (both from libavr's
`tools/atmelstudio/`):
```sh
for name in pureboot tsb_asm; do
python ../libavr/tools/atmelstudio/componentinfo.py \
"ide/$name/$name.componentinfo.xml" --device ATmega328P
python ../libavr/tools/atmelstudio/check-flags.py \
--solution ide/bootloader.atsln --project "$name" --target "$name" \
--compile-commands build/atmega328p-generated/compile_commands.json \
--log "build/as-$name.log"
done
```
`--project` because one reference describes one binary; `--target` because
`pureboot.cpp` is compiled by every point of the size matrix and the flags
differ per point, so the basename alone does not name a reference. Release is
what the gate compares — the presets define no debug build, and Debug differs
from Release only in `-gdwarf-4`.
Legacy (the yazoalfa-era submodules) stays on `master`.

28
ide/bootloader.atsln Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
Microsoft Visual Studio Solution File, Format Version 12.00
# Atmel Studio Solution File, Format Version 11.00
VisualStudioVersion = 14.0.23107.0
MinimumVisualStudioVersion = 10.0.40219.1
Project("{E66E83B9-2572-4076-B26E-6BE79FF3018A}") = "pureboot", "pureboot\pureboot.cppproj", "{99067222-32D5-49E3-B4F8-5ABA0F7722B7}"
EndProject
Project("{E66E83B9-2572-4076-B26E-6BE79FF3018A}") = "tsb_asm", "tsb_asm\tsb_asm.cppproj", "{6618D3BE-7EB3-49A2-9113-F128E396FF06}"
EndProject
Global
GlobalSection(SolutionConfigurationPlatforms) = preSolution
Debug|AVR = Debug|AVR
Release|AVR = Release|AVR
EndGlobalSection
GlobalSection(ProjectConfigurationPlatforms) = postSolution
{99067222-32D5-49E3-B4F8-5ABA0F7722B7}.Debug|AVR.ActiveCfg = Debug|AVR
{99067222-32D5-49E3-B4F8-5ABA0F7722B7}.Debug|AVR.Build.0 = Debug|AVR
{99067222-32D5-49E3-B4F8-5ABA0F7722B7}.Release|AVR.ActiveCfg = Release|AVR
{99067222-32D5-49E3-B4F8-5ABA0F7722B7}.Release|AVR.Build.0 = Release|AVR
{6618D3BE-7EB3-49A2-9113-F128E396FF06}.Debug|AVR.ActiveCfg = Debug|AVR
{6618D3BE-7EB3-49A2-9113-F128E396FF06}.Debug|AVR.Build.0 = Debug|AVR
{6618D3BE-7EB3-49A2-9113-F128E396FF06}.Release|AVR.ActiveCfg = Release|AVR
{6618D3BE-7EB3-49A2-9113-F128E396FF06}.Release|AVR.Build.0 = Release|AVR
EndGlobalSection
GlobalSection(SolutionProperties) = preSolution
HideSolutionNode = FALSE
EndGlobalSection
EndGlobal

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,118 @@
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<Project DefaultTargets="Build" xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/developer/msbuild/2003" ToolsVersion="14.0">
<PropertyGroup>
<SchemaVersion>2.0</SchemaVersion>
<ProjectVersion>7.0</ProjectVersion>
<ToolchainName>com.Atmel.AVRGCC8.CPP</ToolchainName>
<ProjectGuid>99067222-32d5-49e3-b4f8-5aba0f7722b7</ProjectGuid>
<avrdevice>ATmega328P</avrdevice>
<avrdeviceseries>none</avrdeviceseries>
<OutputType>Executable</OutputType>
<Language>CPP</Language>
<OutputFileName>$(MSBuildProjectName)</OutputFileName>
<OutputFileExtension>.elf</OutputFileExtension>
<OutputDirectory>$(MSBuildProjectDirectory)\$(Configuration)</OutputDirectory>
<AssemblyName>pureboot</AssemblyName>
<Name>pureboot</Name>
<RootNamespace>pureboot</RootNamespace>
<ToolchainFlavour>avr-g++-16.1.0</ToolchainFlavour>
<KeepTimersRunning>true</KeepTimersRunning>
<OverrideVtor>false</OverrideVtor>
<CacheFlash>true</CacheFlash>
<ProgFlashFromRam>true</ProgFlashFromRam>
<RamSnippetAddress>0x20000000</RamSnippetAddress>
<UncachedRange />
<preserveEEPROM>true</preserveEEPROM>
<OverrideVtorValue>exception_table</OverrideVtorValue>
<BootSegment>2</BootSegment>
<ResetRule>0</ResetRule>
<eraseonlaunchrule>0</eraseonlaunchrule>
<EraseKey />
<AsfFrameworkConfig>
<framework-data xmlns="">
<options />
<configurations />
<files />
<documentation help="" />
<offline-documentation help="" />
<dependencies>
<content-extension eid="atmel.asf" uuidref="Atmel.ASF" version="3.52.0" />
</dependencies>
</framework-data>
</AsfFrameworkConfig>
</PropertyGroup>
<PropertyGroup Condition=" '$(Configuration)' == 'Release' ">
<ToolchainSettings>
<AvrGccCpp>
<avrgcc.common.Device>-mmcu=atmega328p</avrgcc.common.Device>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.hex>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.hex>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.lss>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.lss>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.eep>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.eep>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.srec>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.srec>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.usersignatures>False</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.usersignatures>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.symbols.DefSymbols>
<ListValues>
<Value>NDEBUG</Value>
<Value>PUREBOOT_CLOCK_HZ=16000000</Value>
<Value>PUREBOOT_BAUD=115200</Value>
<Value>PUREBOOT_TIMEOUT=8</Value>
</ListValues>
</avrgcccpp.compiler.symbols.DefSymbols>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.directories.IncludePaths>
<ListValues>
<Value>$(MSBuildProjectDirectory)\..\..\..\libavr\include</Value>
</ListValues>
</avrgcccpp.compiler.directories.IncludePaths>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.level>Optimize for size (-Os)</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.level>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareFunctionsForGarbageCollection>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareFunctionsForGarbageCollection>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareDataForGarbageCollection>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareDataForGarbageCollection>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.warnings.AllWarnings>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.warnings.AllWarnings>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.miscellaneous.OtherFlags>-std=c++26 -Wextra -Werror -mrelax -fno-exceptions -fno-rtti -fno-threadsafe-statics -fno-ivopts -fira-algorithm=priority -fno-tree-ter -fno-split-wide-types</avrgcccpp.compiler.miscellaneous.OtherFlags>
<avrgcccpp.linker.optimization.GarbageCollectUnusedSections>True</avrgcccpp.linker.optimization.GarbageCollectUnusedSections>
<avrgcccpp.linker.miscellaneous.LinkerFlags>-mrelax -nostartfiles -Wl,--section-start=.text=0x7e00 -Wl,--defsym=pureboot_app=0 -Wl,--pmem-wrap-around=32k</avrgcccpp.linker.miscellaneous.LinkerFlags>
</AvrGccCpp>
</ToolchainSettings>
</PropertyGroup>
<PropertyGroup Condition=" '$(Configuration)' == 'Debug' ">
<ToolchainSettings>
<AvrGccCpp>
<avrgcc.common.Device>-mmcu=atmega328p</avrgcc.common.Device>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.hex>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.hex>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.lss>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.lss>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.eep>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.eep>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.srec>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.srec>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.usersignatures>False</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.usersignatures>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.symbols.DefSymbols>
<ListValues>
<Value>DEBUG</Value>
<Value>PUREBOOT_CLOCK_HZ=16000000</Value>
<Value>PUREBOOT_BAUD=115200</Value>
<Value>PUREBOOT_TIMEOUT=8</Value>
</ListValues>
</avrgcccpp.compiler.symbols.DefSymbols>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.directories.IncludePaths>
<ListValues>
<Value>$(MSBuildProjectDirectory)\..\..\..\libavr\include</Value>
</ListValues>
</avrgcccpp.compiler.directories.IncludePaths>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.level>Optimize for size (-Os)</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.level>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareFunctionsForGarbageCollection>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareFunctionsForGarbageCollection>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareDataForGarbageCollection>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareDataForGarbageCollection>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.warnings.AllWarnings>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.warnings.AllWarnings>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.miscellaneous.OtherFlags>-std=c++26 -Wextra -Werror -mrelax -fno-exceptions -fno-rtti -fno-threadsafe-statics -fno-ivopts -fira-algorithm=priority -fno-tree-ter -fno-split-wide-types -gdwarf-4</avrgcccpp.compiler.miscellaneous.OtherFlags>
<avrgcccpp.linker.optimization.GarbageCollectUnusedSections>True</avrgcccpp.linker.optimization.GarbageCollectUnusedSections>
<avrgcccpp.linker.miscellaneous.LinkerFlags>-mrelax -nostartfiles -Wl,--section-start=.text=0x7e00 -Wl,--defsym=pureboot_app=0 -Wl,--pmem-wrap-around=32k</avrgcccpp.linker.miscellaneous.LinkerFlags>
</AvrGccCpp>
</ToolchainSettings>
</PropertyGroup>
<ItemGroup>
<Compile Include="..\..\pureboot\pureboot.cpp">
<SubType>compile</SubType>
<Link>pureboot\pureboot.cpp</Link>
</Compile>
</ItemGroup>
<ItemGroup>
<Folder Include="pureboot" />
</ItemGroup>
<Import Project="$(AVRSTUDIO_EXE_PATH)\Vs\Compiler.targets" />
</Project>

112
ide/tsb_asm/tsb_asm.cppproj Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,112 @@
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<Project DefaultTargets="Build" xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/developer/msbuild/2003" ToolsVersion="14.0">
<PropertyGroup>
<SchemaVersion>2.0</SchemaVersion>
<ProjectVersion>7.0</ProjectVersion>
<ToolchainName>com.Atmel.AVRGCC8.CPP</ToolchainName>
<ProjectGuid>6618d3be-7eb3-49a2-9113-f128e396ff06</ProjectGuid>
<avrdevice>ATmega328P</avrdevice>
<avrdeviceseries>none</avrdeviceseries>
<OutputType>Executable</OutputType>
<Language>CPP</Language>
<OutputFileName>$(MSBuildProjectName)</OutputFileName>
<OutputFileExtension>.elf</OutputFileExtension>
<OutputDirectory>$(MSBuildProjectDirectory)\$(Configuration)</OutputDirectory>
<AssemblyName>tsb_asm</AssemblyName>
<Name>tsb_asm</Name>
<RootNamespace>tsb_asm</RootNamespace>
<ToolchainFlavour>avr-g++-16.1.0</ToolchainFlavour>
<KeepTimersRunning>true</KeepTimersRunning>
<OverrideVtor>false</OverrideVtor>
<CacheFlash>true</CacheFlash>
<ProgFlashFromRam>true</ProgFlashFromRam>
<RamSnippetAddress>0x20000000</RamSnippetAddress>
<UncachedRange />
<preserveEEPROM>true</preserveEEPROM>
<OverrideVtorValue>exception_table</OverrideVtorValue>
<BootSegment>2</BootSegment>
<ResetRule>0</ResetRule>
<eraseonlaunchrule>0</eraseonlaunchrule>
<EraseKey />
<AsfFrameworkConfig>
<framework-data xmlns="">
<options />
<configurations />
<files />
<documentation help="" />
<offline-documentation help="" />
<dependencies>
<content-extension eid="atmel.asf" uuidref="Atmel.ASF" version="3.52.0" />
</dependencies>
</framework-data>
</AsfFrameworkConfig>
</PropertyGroup>
<PropertyGroup Condition=" '$(Configuration)' == 'Release' ">
<ToolchainSettings>
<AvrGccCpp>
<avrgcc.common.Device>-mmcu=atmega328p</avrgcc.common.Device>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.hex>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.hex>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.lss>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.lss>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.eep>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.eep>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.srec>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.srec>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.usersignatures>False</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.usersignatures>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.symbols.DefSymbols>
<ListValues>
<Value>NDEBUG</Value>
</ListValues>
</avrgcccpp.compiler.symbols.DefSymbols>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.directories.IncludePaths>
<ListValues>
<Value>$(MSBuildProjectDirectory)\..\..\..\libavr\include</Value>
</ListValues>
</avrgcccpp.compiler.directories.IncludePaths>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.level>Optimize for size (-Os)</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.level>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareFunctionsForGarbageCollection>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareFunctionsForGarbageCollection>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareDataForGarbageCollection>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareDataForGarbageCollection>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.warnings.AllWarnings>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.warnings.AllWarnings>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.miscellaneous.OtherFlags>-std=c++26 -Wextra -Werror -mrelax -fno-exceptions -fno-rtti -fno-threadsafe-statics</avrgcccpp.compiler.miscellaneous.OtherFlags>
<avrgcccpp.linker.optimization.GarbageCollectUnusedSections>True</avrgcccpp.linker.optimization.GarbageCollectUnusedSections>
<avrgcccpp.linker.miscellaneous.LinkerFlags>-mrelax -nostartfiles -Wl,--section-start=.text=0x7e00 -Wl,--defsym=tsb_app=0 -Wl,--pmem-wrap-around=32k</avrgcccpp.linker.miscellaneous.LinkerFlags>
</AvrGccCpp>
</ToolchainSettings>
</PropertyGroup>
<PropertyGroup Condition=" '$(Configuration)' == 'Debug' ">
<ToolchainSettings>
<AvrGccCpp>
<avrgcc.common.Device>-mmcu=atmega328p</avrgcc.common.Device>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.hex>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.hex>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.lss>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.lss>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.eep>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.eep>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.srec>True</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.srec>
<avrgcc.common.outputfiles.usersignatures>False</avrgcc.common.outputfiles.usersignatures>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.symbols.DefSymbols>
<ListValues>
<Value>DEBUG</Value>
</ListValues>
</avrgcccpp.compiler.symbols.DefSymbols>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.directories.IncludePaths>
<ListValues>
<Value>$(MSBuildProjectDirectory)\..\..\..\libavr\include</Value>
</ListValues>
</avrgcccpp.compiler.directories.IncludePaths>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.level>Optimize for size (-Os)</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.level>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareFunctionsForGarbageCollection>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareFunctionsForGarbageCollection>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareDataForGarbageCollection>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.optimization.PrepareDataForGarbageCollection>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.warnings.AllWarnings>True</avrgcccpp.compiler.warnings.AllWarnings>
<avrgcccpp.compiler.miscellaneous.OtherFlags>-std=c++26 -Wextra -Werror -mrelax -fno-exceptions -fno-rtti -fno-threadsafe-statics -gdwarf-4</avrgcccpp.compiler.miscellaneous.OtherFlags>
<avrgcccpp.linker.optimization.GarbageCollectUnusedSections>True</avrgcccpp.linker.optimization.GarbageCollectUnusedSections>
<avrgcccpp.linker.miscellaneous.LinkerFlags>-mrelax -nostartfiles -Wl,--section-start=.text=0x7e00 -Wl,--defsym=tsb_app=0 -Wl,--pmem-wrap-around=32k</avrgcccpp.linker.miscellaneous.LinkerFlags>
</AvrGccCpp>
</ToolchainSettings>
</PropertyGroup>
<ItemGroup>
<Compile Include="..\..\tsb\tsb_asm.cpp">
<SubType>compile</SubType>
<Link>tsb\tsb_asm.cpp</Link>
</Compile>
</ItemGroup>
<ItemGroup>
<Folder Include="tsb" />
</ItemGroup>
<Import Project="$(AVRSTUDIO_EXE_PATH)\Vs\Compiler.targets" />
</Project>

2
libavr

Submodule libavr updated: 20d8cdb8aa...10d33d7894